Grand Strategy – five of Chris’ favorites

The Grand Strategy genre offers some of the most complex and immersive titles in gaming. They’re different from other strategy games available for the PC. Grand Strategy puts you in control of every major aspect of your faction focusing on high level decision making affecting whole continents. Instead of playing on puny battlefields your interface is a map of the world.

Here’s a list of five of my favorite titles which will satisfy your cravings for building empires and slaughtering masses.

5# Knights of Honour

This is the oldest grand strategy game on this list.  It’s one of the highest rated on Steam and continues to impress. With its high level strategy taking place on a map spanning all of Europe, Black Sea Studios have done a fantastic job of creating an extremely deep medieval kingdom simulation.  The idea in Knights of Honour is to take command of one of more than 100 countries from three eras of European history.  Your twin goals are to survive and expand.  This doesn’t just mean improving your economy and military but also arranging marriages and dispatching spies to enemy nations.

favorite grand strategy games pc - siege

The Game’s Ambition

This is a fairly ambitious game, and mostly, it works incredibly well.  The in-game interface is elegant and the game mechanics well thought out.  The pace is steady, a standard game can span hours of playing time and centuries of European history.  At the heart of your empire are provinces, each containing a central town which must be conquered in order to win the province. These towns are the source of your food, wealth and armies.  Some towns have access to bonus resources; for instance a town may have rich pasture land which supports cattle and sheep. These animal resources aren’t just a source of food but also produce leather and which can be used to trade and help with diplomatic relations.

favorite grand strategy games pc - Knights of Honour

Disappointing Combat

The combat is  resolved in one of two ways.  You can let your Marshal fight the battle himself, allowing you to focus on other things or you take control of the conflict yourself. When you do, the map drops down to a 2D representation of the battlefield and you control your forces by choosing and maneuvering formations.  Directing these battles can be extremely tricky and a downside to the game.

It’s the main reason that I dropped this title to the lowest number on the list. I enjoy the combat element of grand strategy and while not fatally flawed they did slightly detract from my overall enjoyment of this title.  However it’s overarching campaign and accurate historical depictions won me over and I spent many hours directing the fate of European nations. With numerous mechanics to keep you busy, from religion to economics, your quest to become Emperor of Europe will be a unique and exciting one. If you enjoy the experience, massive modpacks are essentially free sequels.

Available on Steam

4# Galactic Civilisations III

Set in the far future, Galactic Civilisations starts the player out with only one planet to control. You then expand through diplomacy, colonisation and war.  In a massive galaxy with enormous factions vying for power using both peaceful and military means, Galactic Civilisations will put you in the middle of an interstellar war of total domination.

This is a game series which sits alongside Master of Orion but with that series’ drop in quality, Galactic Civilisations comes out in front.  Where this title excels is the characterisation. It’s not just a game about rules and statistics. There’s an attempt to make you feel that the aliens you encounter have personalities instead of being a rendered face on stats.

favorite grand strategy games pc - Civ Aliens

Mature Morality System

I rank this number four on the list because the current iteration of the series has removed the overarching political element that was so prevalent in the previous games.  There are no elections, no governments and most regrettably, no spying mechanic. Past games had an exciting good/evil system but where this title proves it’s evolution is in its mature, moral decision making. The new designations of Malevolent, Pragmatic and Beneficial gain points as you make decisions. These points can be cashed in for special perks.  The perks range from free colony ships to galaxy affecting boosts like causing all other civilizations to declare war on any race who attacks you.

favorite grand strategy games pc - galactic civilizations 3 - morality

Taken as a whole, Galactic Civilization’s failings are minor. For most games, a few major pieces that don’t quite fit together are a death knell. Galactic Civilizations keeps its focus right where it needs to – on excellent fundamentals. Progressive pacing makes the enormity of space amenable and paradoxically personal, while the sheer number and variety of tools and options at your disposal allow you to succeed and win if you can out-think everyone else.

Available on Steam

3#Hearts of Iron IV

From Paradox studios, this title exemplifies the technical advances that WWII Grand Strategy has undergone in the last few years.  Paradox used their own Clausewitz game engine in this latest release and it certainly shows it’s adaptability and utility. This game engine captures the essence of the era; the rivalries and discoveries that defined it and how all these elements shaped the world.  In Hearts of Iron IV all roads lead to destruction as players use the tools of progress to win a spectacular international strategic deathmatch.

favorite grand strategy games pc - Hearts of Iron

Tightly Focused Gameplay

Hearts of Iron is different from Paradox’s other grand strategy games (Europa Universalis III I’m looking at you here) being a scenario rather than a sandbox;  a very big, complicated scenario that can play out in many, many different ways.  To really enjoy it you have to understand that it’s not the sort of game where you can choose from multiple factions and freely guide their destinies, rather the choices are starker.  As Germany, do you want to attack Russia now or wait until they attack you first? These are the crucial and pivotal questions you’ll be asking yourself.  Because of it’s smaller, tighter focus, I found this title to be one of the more intense Grand Strategy games.

favorite grand strategy games pc - strategic map

The element which detracts from this game is the combat. Like all of Paradox’s titles, there’s an issue with making the military battles palpable and intuitive.  There are so many complex variables and statistics at play during a battle.  Each unit has so many statistics that affect performance that it becomes over-complicated.  On the battlefield it’s fairly easy to see the effects of new technologies, but elements like “mass attack doctrine” have no noticeable impact on the myriad of battles you will face during gametime.  Having said this, if you purchase Hearts of Iron IV, you will get a beautiful, thrilling wargame which successfully orchestrates the most titanic battles of World War II’s history.

Available on Steam

2# Total War : Warhammer

Dwarfs line the walls of the Everpeak, weapons ready. They fire bolt and lead at the incoming Orcs, but to the giant lummoxing forward at the head of the green horde it may as well be a light smither of rain. The giant crashes into the gates, stumbles back and crashes into them again. It bursts through, met by massed units of Longbeards, fearless dwarf veterans, who mob the giant like dogs harassing an elephant.

They win, because in the rock, paper, scissors of Total War: Warhammer the Longbeards’ immunity to psychological effects makes them ideal for fighting fear-causing giants.

favorite grand strategy games pc - Total War Warhammer 2

Moving away from it’s traditional historical setting into the realm of fantasy was a bold move for Total War and even bolder to feature the Warhammer universe. I believe however it was an incredibly intelligent move and is definitely one of the best Grand Strategy titles on the market today.  In Total War: Warhammer, the player chooses a faction, conducts diplomacy, trade and economic development on a large map of the world.  The battles are then played out on a separate battlefield stage in real time.

Comprehensive Faction Choice

There are a total of 12 playable factions. These vary considerably in detail, making each play through as a different race a truly unique experience. This variety is present in both the turn based map element and the real time battles.  Dwarfs don’t have wizards but do have mighty artillery and are more defensive.  Vampire Counts have mages but not missile launchers (although I would have loved to have seen some zombie archers!), they generally shamble around targeting specific units with zombie knights and flying creatures.

The green skinned orcs have a bit of everything but when cornered they lose their nerve and often flee.  This attention to detail in both crafting the various factions and creating graphically and visually arresting units (I love zooming in on the battlefield and watching my mohawk haired Orcs do battle with Zombies) is why I have placed this as one of my second favourite grand strategy titles.

Available on Steam

#1 XCOM 2

XCOM 2 is one of the all time greats of the tactics genre. It takes the best bits from the series so far – the savage struggle, the ragtag group of heroes, the devious aliens, the tight tactical battles – and throws improvement after improvement on top. Once again, you are sending small squads into the breach, but this time as a group of struggling survivors fighting against a tyrannical alien regime.

It is all guerilla tactics, covert missions, and dissidence. You need to learn to make sacrifices, leaving men and women behind so you can save the rest, and you need to learn to swallow loss and failure.  The battles are challenging and varied, full of horrific adversaries with tricky, surprising abilities.

The biggest change to the game is at the strategic layer . Why else would it be on a list of the best strategy games on PC? You will travel all over the world, setting up cells, infiltrating black sites, hunting for more resources so you can field more powerful weapons and tools. It’s compelling rather than an afterthought.

favorite grand strategy games pc - xcom 2 squad

Game Improvements

XCOM 2 embraces a new form of thought from its predecessor.  In base management you now allocate individual engineers as human upgrades to your comms and other systems. You won’t come around to it right away. But once you do you will find yourself thinking around your strategic problems in callous new ways.

This is a guerrilla fight, in which familiar mechanics are refitted to tell a very different story. An untimed mission in which you might take a turn just to heal and reload everybody’s weapons is a luxury you’re rarely afforded. Far more often you’re racing to an objective and then to an evac point. One you’ve placed yourself or, cruelly, a fixed point on the other side of the map.

Frequently, you’ll be rushed by the appearance of a red flare burning away on the tarmac. This is the harbinger of a shipful of reinforcements for the next turn.  Anybody who doesn’t reach the evac zone is captured, or for the purposes of the campaign, dead. It’s harsh. Unbending. And yet the fact that you’re unconcerned about mopping up every last enemy on the map is freeing.

favorite grand strategy games pc - xcom 2 map

 

 

  • Posts
Chris McAuley Author
Chris McAuley began his writing career reviewing old copies of 2000AD, he quickly progressed to interviewing major alumni of the comic book industry including Pat Mills, Grant Morrison, Glenn Fabry. Writing acclaimed reviews and features on Comic books and videogames, he is also a Test Reader for Millsverse. His background is in theology and it is in this arena which he gained his PHD, believing that story is crucial to human beings and that most modern cultural narrative experiences are driven from the ancient and the mythological. These are the aspects of gaming which Chris gravitates towards – narrative and immersive experience. He is dedicated to exploring and explaining the important aspects of the gameplay experience of the titles he reviews and informing the reader so that they can make the best decision regarding their purchases.
follow me
May 20, 2018
Street Fighter II was a game that changed the world. At the time Hyper Street Fighter II was released to celebrate the 15th anniversary of the original game.  Street Fighter II thundered into the arcades worldwide and it’s shockwaves are still felt today.  While Capcom is known for some well milked titles, I would argue […]
May 19, 2018
Going through the multiple Street Fighter related properties in celebration of the 30th Anniversary of the most popular fighting gaming franchise on the earth.  I couldn’t neglect one of the best animated movies of the 90’s.  Street Fighter II: The Animated Movie manages to service both fans of the game and also newcomers. It features […]
May 17, 2018
Crime and corruption, two words that go hand in hand with any big city.  In Metro City it’s also an aspect of daily life.  A powerful street gang – Mad Gear has political and business connection and unparalleled resources.  The citizens of this urban wasteland face another night of despair and danger, all due to […]
May 17, 2018
This is something of an oddity when it comes to the Street Fighter franchise.  This is a sequel to the original Street Fighter and released just before Street Fighter 2 hit the scene and completely changed how we view gaming forever.  We find out through this game that Ken’s true burning passion wasn’t fighting in […]
May 16, 2018
It’s 1991, the arcades are still booming, those fortunes are beginning to reverse however.  Due to the popularity of home consoles and the availability of a multitude of game genres on those systems the arcades are beginning to empty.  However one game starts to initially reverse that tendency however.  Street Fighter II with it’s incredible […]
×
Chris McAuley Author
Chris McAuley began his writing career reviewing old copies of 2000AD, he quickly progressed to interviewing major alumni of the comic book industry including Pat Mills, Grant Morrison, Glenn Fabry. Writing acclaimed reviews and features on Comic books and videogames, he is also a Test Reader for Millsverse. His background is in theology and it is in this arena which he gained his PHD, believing that story is crucial to human beings and that most modern cultural narrative experiences are driven from the ancient and the mythological. These are the aspects of gaming which Chris gravitates towards – narrative and immersive experience. He is dedicated to exploring and explaining the important aspects of the gameplay experience of the titles he reviews and informing the reader so that they can make the best decision regarding their purchases.
Latest Posts
  • warhammer 40k betrayal at calth - feature

What did you think?

You may like

In the news
Load More